Against Liberal Muslims: Re-reading Boarding Schools’ Sanad-ijazah and Kyai-santri Through Gadamer and Lakatos’ Lens
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.51498/putih.2026.11(1).67-93Keywords:
Gadamerian hermeneutics, Lakatos research programme, sanad-ijazah, pesantren, Liberal MuslimsAbstract
This study critically analyzes the necessity of having a teacher within the Indonesian Islamic boarding school (pesantren) tradition through the lens of classical Islamic epistemology and contemporary philosophy of science. Employing qualitative hermeneutic-analytical approach based on library research adn focus group discussion, this investigation examines the epistemological validity of the teacher-student transmission system that has become the target of criticism from modern liberal Muslims such as Guru Gembul. The theoretical framework combines Hans-Georg Gadamer's philosophical hermeneutics (fusion of horizons) with Imre Lakatos's methodology of scientific research programmes to evaluate the pesantren tradition. Key findings reveal that: (1) the Arab-Islamic oral tradition practiced in pesantren is a sophisticated quality control system that anticipated insights of modern hermeneutics; (2) the sanad-ijazah system instantiates Gadamerian fusion of horizons where knowledge transmission is a dialogical encounter between tradition and context; (3) within Lakatos's, the pesantren tradition demonstrates characteristics of a progressive research programme over centuries, while liberal Muslim critiques exhibit mixed-evaluation; (4) critiques of "intellectual dependence" on teachers reveal a category mistake assuming epistemological autonomy ex-nihilo. This research contributes to contemporary Islamic epistemology discourse by demonstrating the necessity for epistemological justice that acknowledges the complexity of Islamic scholarly traditions often subordinated in modern discourse.
Downloads
References
Aczel, Balazs, Ann-Sophie Barwich, Amanda B Diekman, and Ayelet Fishbach. “The Present and Future of Peer Review: Ideas, Interventions, and Evidence.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 122, no. 5 (2025): 1–9. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.240123212.
Al-Attas, Syed Muhammad Naquib. Islam and Secularism. 2nd ed. International Institute of Islamic Thought and Civilization (ISTAC), 1993.
———. The Concept of Education in Islam: A Framework for an Islamic Philosophy of Education. International Institute of Islamic Thought and Civilization (ISTAC), 1980.
Al-Ghazāli, Abū Hāmid Muhammad. Ihya ’Ulm Ad-Din. Dār al-Ma’rifah, 1998.
Al-Khathib al-Baghdādi. Al-Kifāyah Fi ’Ilm Al-Riwāyah. Dār al-Kutub al-’Ilmiyyah, 2001.
Al-Suyūthi, J. Tadrib Al-Rāwi Fi Shardh Taqrib Al-Nawawi. Dār al-’Āshimah, 2005.
Al-Zarnuji. Ta’lim Muta’allim (Akhlak Santri). Al-Maktub al-Badami, 1981.
Ali, Mufti. “How Did Al-Suyuthi Abridge Ibn Taymiyya’s Nashihat Akl Al-Iman Fi Al-Radd ’ala Mantiq Al-Yunan.” Al-Jami’ah 46, no. 2 (2008): 279–302.
Anam, Syaiful, Moh Alpa Hosim, and Ainol Yaqin. “TRANSFORMATION OF PESANTREN ECONOMIC MANAGEMENT TOWARD SELF-RELIANCE BASED ON LOCAL WISDOM.” Jurnal Kajian Ekonomi Dan Perbankan Syariah 9, no. 1 (2025): 72–80. https://doi.org/10.33650/profit.v9i1.11108.
Arifin, Zainal. “KEPEMIMPINAN KIAI DALAM IDEOLOGISASI PEMIKIRAN SANTRI DI PESANTREN-PESANTREN SALAFIYAH MLANGI YOGYAKARTA.” INFERENSI: Jurnal Penelitian Sosial Keagamaan 9, no. 2 (December 1, 2015): 351–72. https://doi.org/10.18326/INFSL3.V9I2.351-372.
Asyibli, Basri, Aqila Azharrani Ibtihal, Mochamad Fikri Fauzan, Anis Fauzi, and Wahyu Hidayat. “Epistemological Dimensions in Islamic Educational Philosophy: A Critical Analysis.” Journal of Islamic Education Research 6, no. 1 (February 11, 2025). https://doi.org/10.35719/jier.v6i1.464.
Bartley, Kevin A., and Jeffrey J. Brooks. “Fusion of Horizons: Realizing a Meaningful Understanding in Qualitative Research.” Sage Journals Qualitative Research 23, no. 4 (August 1, 2023): 940–61. https://doi.org/10.1177/14687941211065164.
Baumgartner, Peter, and Ingrid Grundschober. “Is Tacit Knowledge Communicable?” In Proceedings of the International Conference on Cognition and Exploratory Learning in Digital Age, 11–20, 2017.
Blecher, Joel. Said the Prophet of God: Hadith Commentary across a Millennium. University of California Press, 2018.
Brown, Jonathan A C. Authenticating Hadith and the History of Hadith Criticism. Yaqeen Institute for Islamic Research. Yaqeen Institute for Islamic Research, 2021. https://yaqeeninstitute.org/read/paper/authenticating-hadith-and-the-history-of-hadith-criticism.
———. Blind Spots: The Origins of the Western Method of Critiquing Hadith. Yaqeen Institute for Islamic Research, 2019. https://yaqeeninstitute.org/read/paper/blind-spots-the-origins-of-the-western-method-of-critiquing-hadith.
———. Hadith: Muhammad’s Legacy in the Medieval and Modern World. 2nd ed. Oneworld Publications, 2017.
———. “How We Know Early Hadith Critics Did Matn Criticism and Why It’s So Hard to Find.” Islamic Law and Society 15, no. 2 (2008): 143–84. https://doi.org/10.1163/156851908X290538.
———. Misquoting Muhammad: The Challenge and Choices of Interpreting the Prophet’s Legacy. Oneworld Publications, 2015.
Bruinessen, Martin van. Kitab Kuning, Pesantren, Dan Tarekat: Tradisi-Tradisi Islam Di Indonesia. Rev. Gading Publishing, 2015.
———. “Pesantren and Kitab Kuning: Continuity and Change in a Tradition of Religious Learning.” In Texts from the Islands: Oral and Written Traditions of Indonesia and the Malay World, edited by Wolfgang Marschall, 121–46. University of Berne, 1994.
Dhofier, Zamakhsyari. Tradisi Pesantren: Studi Pandangan Hidup Kyai Dan Visinya Mengenai Masa Depan Indonesia. Rev. LP3ES, 2015.
Dzakirul, Hafizh. “10 Kritik Pedas Guru Gembul Untuk Pesantren: Sudah Saatnya Berbenah.” Kompasiana.com, 2025. https://www.kompasiana.com/hafizhdzakirul1703/68efdf56c925c43b3161aab3/.
Enworo, Oko Chima. “Application of Guba and Lincoln’s Parallel Criteria to Assess Trustworthiness of Qualitative Research on Indigenous Social Protection Systems.” Qualitative Research Journal 23, no. 4 (April 24, 2023): 372–84. https://doi.org/10.1108/QRJ-08-2022-0116.
Fajarudin, Akhmad Afnan. “Pesantren: A Potrait of Education and Islamic Social History.” Journal of Islamic Education Research 5, no. 2 (June 12, 2024): 91–108. https://doi.org/10.35719/jier.v5i2.406.
Farih, Amin. “NAHDLATUL ULAMA (NU) DAN KONTRIBUSINYA DALAM MEMPERJUANGKAN KEMERDEKAAN DAN MEMPERTAHANKAN NEGARA KESATUAN REPUBLIK INDONESIA (NKRI).” Jurnal Penelitian Sosial Keagamaan 24, no. 2 (2016): 251–84. https://doi.org/10.21580/ws.2016.24.2.969.
Firdasari, Auliya Adiba Rahma, and M. Yunus Abu Bakar. “Pendidikan Islam Perspektif Al-Ghazali: Integrasi Nilai-Nilai Spiritual Dan Akhlak Dalam Pembelajaran.” PUTIH: Jurnal Pengetahuan Tentang Ilmu Dan Hikmah 10, no. 1 (April 8, 2025): 73–92. https://doi.org/10.51498/putih.2025.10(1).73-92.
Gadamer, Hans-Georg. Philosophical Hermeneutics. Translated by David E Linge. University of California Press, 1976.
———. Truth and Method. Translated by Joel Weinsheimer and Donald G Marshall. 2nd rev. Bloomsbury Academic, 2013.
Garrison, Douglas H. “Ibn Khaldun and the Modern Social Sciences: A Comparative Theoretical Inquiry into Society, the State, and Revolution.” University of Denver, 2012. https://digitalcommons.du.edu/etd/231.
Gibbs, Scott. “Islam and Islamic Extremism: An Existential Analysis.” Journal of Humanistic Psychology 45, no. 2 (2005): 156–203. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022167805274728
Görke, Andreas, and Gregor Schoeler. “Reconstructing the Earliest Sira Texts: The Hiğra in the Corpus of Urwa b. Al-Zubayr.” Der Islam 82, no. 2 (2005): 209–20. https://doi.org/10.1515/islm.2005.82.2.209.
———. The Earliest Writings on the Life of Muḥammad: The ʿUrwa Corpus and the Non-Muslim Sources. Berlin: Gerlach Press, 2024.
Hakim, Dian Mohammad. “Transformasi Kurikulum Pesantren Melalui Metode Pembelajaran Kitab Kuning Dalam Mengembangkan Pesantren : Studi Kasus Di Pondok Pesantren Al-Hikam Malang.” Andragogi : Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan Agama Islam 1, no. 2 (January 10, 2019): 39–49. https://doi.org/10.33474/JA.V1I2.4975.
Hallaq, Wael B. Restating Orientalism: A Critique of Modern Knowledge. Columbia University Press, 2018.
Hamdeh, Emad. “Shaykh Google as Ḥāfiẓ Al-ʿAṣr.” American Journal of Islam and Society 37, no. 1–2 (May 15, 2020): 67–102. https://doi.org/10.35632/ajis.v37i1-2.851.
Hidayatulloh, M. Syarif. “Pembelajaran Kontekstual Dalam Kegiatan Bahtsul Masail Santri Di Pondok Pesantren Al-Muhibbin Bahrul Ulum Tambakberas Jombang.” Nazhruna: Jurnal Pendidikan Islam 1, no. 2 (August 19, 2018): 177–200. https://doi.org/10.31538/NZH.V1I2.50.
Husnawadi, Husnawadi. “A Correlational Study of the Bahtsul Masail Method, Learning Motivation, and Students’ Understanding of Islamic Law.” AS-SABIQUN 7, no. 3 (May 1, 2025): 509–21. https://doi.org/10.36088/ASSABIQUN.V7I3.5692.
Ibn Khaldūn. Al-Muqaddimah: An Introduction to History. Edited by N J Dawood. Translated by Franz Rosenthal. Princeton University Press, 2015.
Ibriy, Ahmad Chuvav. “Kritik Pesantren: Antara Ilusi Kebangkitan Kiri Dan Bayangan Ekstrem Kanan.” Alif.id, 2025. https://alif.id/tradisi/kritik-pesantren-antara-ilusi-kebangkitan-kiri-dan-bayangan-esktrem-kanan.
Ja’far, A Khumaedi. “GOOD CORPORATE GOVERNANCE PADA LEMBAGA PENDIDIKAN PESANTREN: STUDI PADA PONDOK PESANTREN UNIVERSITAS ISLAM INDONESIA.” Akademika : Jurnal Pemikiran Islam 23, no. 1 (September 19, 2018): 197–216. https://doi.org/10.32332/AKADEMIKA.V23I1.1216.
Kamali, Mohammad Hashim. “Extremism , Terrorism and Islam : Historical and Contemporary Perspectives.” Islam and Civilisational Renewal 6, no. 2 (January 1, 2015): 148–65. https://doi.org/10.12816/0019163.
Khan, Niaz Ahmed, and Shireen Abedin. “Focus Group Discussion.” Principles of Social Research Methodology, January 1, 2022, 377–87. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-19-5441-2_26.
Kholilah, Iis. “HERMENEUTICS OF NATIONALITY FIQH: STUDY OF BAHTSUL MASAIL OF LIRBOYO ALUMNI ASSOCIATION.” Khazanah: Jurnal Studi Islam Dan Humaniora 17, no. 1 (July 29, 2019): 83–106. https://doi.org/10.18592/KHAZANAH.V17I1.2884.
Kirin, Arwansyah bin, Mohd Hisyam Abdul Rahim, Muhammad Hafis Mohd Hussain, Edriagus Saputra, and Ramdan Baba. “An Analytical Study of the Tahqiq Methodology of ʿAbd Al-Fattah Abu Ghuddah in His Work Al-Rafʿu Wa Al-Takmil Fī Al-Jarh Wa Al-Taʿdil.” International Journal of Research and Innovation in Social Science IX, no. VII (2025): 5079–91. https://doi.org/10.47772/IJRISS.2025.907000410.
Kisihandi, Ferry. “Membaca Kembali Pesantren: Antara Tradisi, Liberalisme, Dan Krisis Pengetahuan Modern.” Republika.co.id, 2025. https://rejabar.republika.co.id/berita/t4b2ds472/.
Koberidze, Giorgi. “The Crisis of Secular Democracy in Turkey: Historical Dynamics and the Rise of Political Islam.” Journal of Politics and Democratization 5 (2024): 1–16.
Kurzman, Charles. Liberal Islam: A Sourcebook. Edited by Charles Kurzman. Oxford University Press, 1998.
Kusumoto, Fred M., John A. Bittl, Mark A. Creager, Harold L. Dauerman, Anuradha Lala, Mary M. McDermott, Justine Varieur Turco, Viviany R. Taqueti, and Valentin Fuster. “Challenges and Controversies in Peer Review: JACC Review Topic of the Week.” Journal of the American College of Cardiology. Elsevier Inc., November 21, 2023. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jacc.2023.08.056.
Lakatos, Imre. “Falsification and the Methodology of Scientific Research Programmes.” In Criticism and the Growth of Knowledge, edited by Imre Lakatos and Alan Musgrave, 91–196. Cambridge University Press, 1970.
Lave, Jean, and Etienne Wenger. Situated Learning: Legitimate Peripheral Participation. Camridge: Cambridge University Press, 1991. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511815355.
Leung, Lawrence. “Validity, Reliability, and Generalizability in Qualitative Research.” Journal of Family Medicine and Primary Care 4, no. 3 (2015): 324. https://doi.org/10.4103/2249-4863.161306.
Lyon, Lucinda J. “Development of Teaching Expertise Viewed through the Dreyfus Model of Skill Acquisition.” Journal of the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning, September 15, 2014, 88–105. https://doi.org/10.14434/josotl.v15i1.12866.
MacIntyre, Alasdair. Whose Justice? Which Rationality? University of Chicago Press, 1988.
Mohamad, Mohamad Redha Bin, Muhammad Zaid Bin Shamsul Kamar, and Shaharuddin Bin Saad. “KEPENTINGAN SANAD DALAM MENJAGA KEASLIAN AL-QURAN.” In Proceeding of The International Conference On Contemporary Issues In Al-Quran And Hadith 2018 (THIQAH 2018), 978–967. Selangor, 2018.
Muhammad, Farhad, Amir Maliki Abitolkha, and Limas Dodi. “Dimensions of Sufism Within The Islamic Religious Education Curriculum in Higher Education.” Nazhruna: Jurnal Pendidikan Islam 7, no. 1 (February 22, 2024): 40–58. https://doi.org/10.31538/nzh.v7i1.4525.
Munir, Munir. “The Continuity and Change of Pesantren Tradition: Study Network Main Pesantren and Alumni Pesantren in Kabupaten OKU Timur, South Sumatra.” Jurnal Pendidikan Islam 5, no. 2 (December 16, 2016): 347–64. https://doi.org/10.14421/JPI.2016.52.347-364.
Murer, Jeffrey Stevenson. “THE MYTH OF AUTONOMY : SUBJECTIVITY, HETERONOMY AND THE VIOLENCE OF LIBERALISM INDIVIDUALISM.” In Polish Political Science, 39:126–48. Sciendo, 2010.
Musgrave, Alan, and Charles Pigden. “Imre Lakatos.” In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N Zalta, Spring 2016. Stanford University, 2016. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/lakatos/.
Nazar, Reza Fauzi. “Marahnya Santri: Pesantren, Kuasa, Dan Krisis Representasi.” Diskursus.id, 2025. https://diskursus.id/marahnya-santri-pesantren-kuasa-dan-krisis-representasi/.
NU Online. “NU Online Raih Penghargaan Inovasi Produk Dan Teknologi Terbaik Dalam AMSI Awards 2025.” nu.or.id, 2024. https://nu.or.id/nasional/nu-online-raih-penghargaan-inovasi-produk-dan-teknologi-terbaik-dalam-amsi-awards-2025-LqEbL.
Nurkhin, Ahmad, Abdul Rohman, and Tri Jatmiko Wahyu Prabowo. “Accountability of Pondok Pesantren; a Systematic Literature Review.” Cogent Business & Management 11, no. 1 (December 31, 2024). https://doi.org/10.1080/23311975.2024.2332503.
Onyenekwe, Chukwuemeka C. “Gadamer’s Fusion of Horizon.” Philosophy and Praxis 10, no. 1 (2020): 71–85.
Pergerakan Indonesia Untuk Semua. “Guru Gembul Kritik Tradisi Di Pesantren.” Gerakanpis.id, 2025. https://gerakanpis.id/guru-gembul-kritik-tradisi-di-pesantren/.
Pertierra, Iñaki Xavier Larrauri. “On Gadamerian Hermeneutics: Fusions of Horizons, Dialogue, and Evolution(s) within Culture as Dynamic System of Meaning.” Eidos: A Journal for Philosophy of Culture 4, no. 4 (2020): 45–62. https://doi.org/10.14394/eidos.jpc.2020.0040.
Polanyi, Michael. Personal Knowledge: Towards a Post-Critical Philosophy. University of Chicago Press, 2013.
Pollefeyt, Didier. “Religious Education as Opening the Hermeneutical Space.” Journal of Religious Education 68, no. 2 (July 2020): 115. https://doi.org/10.1007/S40839-020-00105-7.
Qudus Al Faruq, Abdul, Muhammad Azhar Fuadi, and Mubarok Mubarok. “Pengaruh Historisitas Terhadap Perbedaan Kajian Al-Qur’an Barat Dan Timur.” PUTIH: Jurnal Pengetahuan Tentang Ilmu Dan Hikmah 9, no. 2 (September 22, 2024): 39–60. https://doi.org/10.51498/jq6ezt32.
Rahman, Fazlur. Islam and Modernity: Transformation of an Intellectual Tradition. University of Chicago Press, 1982.
Ridha, Muhammad, Novera Martilova, Nofri Andy.N, and Awada Vera. “Teacher Student Relationship in Pesantren Tradition: A Comparative Study of Pesantren MTI Canduang Agam and Pesantren Darunnahdlatain Pancor Lombok.” El -Hekam 10, no. 1 (June 25, 2025): 1–13. https://doi.org/10.31958/JEH.V10I1.14134.
Said, E W. Culture and Imperialism. Knopf, 1993.
Salam, Muhammad Yusuf, Suharmon, Muhammad Husni Shidqi, Satri Yozi, and Dedi Jistio. “Tradisi Keilmuan Pesantren Melalui Integrasi Sorogan Dan Bandongan Dalam Pembelajaran Kitab Kuning Di Sumatera Barat.” Jurnal Pendidikan Agama Islam 16, no. 2 (2019): 145–68.
Sarsour, Ouael. “Why Did the Arab Spring Fail? Was It a Revolution?” International Journal of Humanities, Social Sciences and Education 8, no. 6 (2021): 56–60. https://doi.org/10.20431/2349-0381.0806008.
Schoeler, Gregor. The Oral and the Written in Early Islam. Edited by James E Montgomery. Translated by Uwe Vagelpohl. Routledge, 2006.
Soueid, Mostafa, and Rita Merhej. “Understanding Islamic Extremism Away from the Dominant Normative Paradigm.” Journal of Ethnic and Cultural Studies 11, no. 1 (January 11, 2024): 183–209. https://doi.org/10.29333/EJECS/1664.
Taufikin. “Hermeneutic of Pesantren with the ‘Fusion of Horizons’’’ Gadamer’s Theory.’” Southeast Asian Journal of Islamic Education 1, no. 1 (2018): 36–58. https://doi.org/10.21093/sajie.v1i1.1335.
Togia, Aspasia, and Afrodite Malliari. “Research Methods in Library and Information Science.” In Qualitative versus Quantitative Research. InTech, 2017. https://doi.org/10.5772/intechopen.68749.
Ulya, Zihniatul, Mujahidin Abubakar, and Lalu Diraja Hidayatullah. “Peran Pondok Pesantren Dalam Mengentaskan Kenakalan Santri.” PUTIH: Jurnal Pengetahuan Tentang Ilmu Dan Hikmah 9, no. 2 (September 15, 2024): 77–98. https://doi.org/10.51498/mtqswa44.
Wada, Larry E, Ejike E Aroh, and Paul C Wagozie. “Imre Lakatos’s Scientific Research Programme: A Critical Evaluation.” International Journal of Research and Innovation in Social Science 7, no. 9 (2023): 117–29. https://doi.org/10.47772/IJRISS.2023.70912.
Ware, Rudolph T., I I I. The Walking Qur’an: Islamic Education, Embodied Knowledge, and History in West Africa. North Carolina: University of North Carolina Press, 2014. https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.5149/9781469614328_ware.
Zigler, Ronald Lee. “Tacit Knowledge and Spiritual Pedagogy.” Journal of Beliefs and Values 20, no. 2 (1999): 162–72. https://doi.org/10.1080/1361767990200206.
Zuhri, Mishbah Khoiruddin, and Mundhir Mundhir. “Transcending Paradigm: Bridging Spirituality and Modern Science in the Thoughts of Nasr, Al-Attas, and Al-Faruqi.” Jurnal Theologia 34, no. 2 (January 24, 2023): 221–44. https://doi.org/10.21580/TEO.2023.34.2.18692.
